marvell
Archie Club Member
Reged: Feb 05 2006
Posts: 23
|
|
PGX graded
white pages
guess the grade! [image] [/image]
|
deathlok
G-Man Uber Poster
Reged: Jan 17 2006
Posts: 653
|
|
9.2
--------------------
Join The fight!
|
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
|
|
A bit of a miswrap there. The Grading Bastiche says....8.5
--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!
|
marvell
Archie Club Member
Reged: Feb 05 2006
Posts: 23
|
|
[image] [/image]
|
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
|
|
Wow, I must be the world's mightiest Grading Bastiche!!!! I would not, send that one into CGC!!
--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!
|
deathlok
G-Man Uber Poster
Reged: Jan 17 2006
Posts: 653
|
|
Quote:
A bit of a miswrap there. The Grading Bastiche says....8.5
A miswrap is not a flaw for grading.
--------------------
Join The fight!
|
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
|
|
It is in my book!!!!
--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!
|
deathlok
G-Man Uber Poster
Reged: Jan 17 2006
Posts: 653
|
|
Quote:
It is in my book!!!!
Yeah, but you aren't the one grading the book, PGX is. Maybe that's why your grading is always off.
--------------------
Join The fight!
|
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
|
|
You would be surprised how accurate I am. I counted off more for spine wear and the top edge of the book. Now, that could be the holder but without having the book in front of me well...8.5 for that bad boy!!!!
--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!
|
marvell
Archie Club Member
Reged: Feb 05 2006
Posts: 23
|
|
Quote:
You would be surprised how accurate I am. I counted off more for spine wear and the top edge of the book. Now, that could be the holder but without having the book in front of me well...8.5 for that bad boy!!!!
Tim i think you would grade it higher if you had the book in front of you! This book is at least a 9.2 and i feel confident you would think so if you held it in hand -the colors and whiteness are amazing! Grading from a scan is a strange art! 
|
deathlok
G-Man Uber Poster
Reged: Jan 17 2006
Posts: 653
|
|
Quote:
Tim i think you would grade it higher if you had the book in front of you! This book is at least a 9.2 and i feel confident you would think so if you held it in hand -the colors and whiteness are amazing! Grading from a scan is a strange art!
He would probably still grade it the same.
--------------------
Join The fight!
|
Ben Grimm
Rang-A-Tang Club Member
Reged: Oct 19 2005
Posts: 61
|
|
I know I'm late, but I would have thought 9.4. The miswrap doesn't count to the "pro" graders, so I kept that in mind, that said, it's got sharp corners, nice color, and nothing obvious wrong with it.
Nice book!!
--------------------
It a hobby, it's supposed to be fun, right?
|
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
Tim i think you would grade it higher if you had the book in front of you! This book is at least a 9.2 and i feel confident you would think so if you held it in hand -the colors and whiteness are amazing! Grading from a scan is a strange art!
He would probably still grade it the same.
Damn, skippy!!! 
--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!
|
SigRollins
Rang-A-Tang Club Member
Reged: Jan 25 2006
Posts: 85
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
A bit of a miswrap there. The Grading Bastiche says....8.5
A miswrap is not a flaw for grading.
Miswrapped, and far more severely mis-cut (alot of serrating and slanted alignment on the right edge), but CGC typically won't deduct grading points for those types of factory flaws, although they should. Any defect that impacts the structural integrity of the paper, whether incurred at the factory or after distribution, like the rough cut that left its mark on this book's right edge, should affect the grade.
|
clayallen
Total Newbie
Reged: Feb 13 2008
Posts: 5
|
|
Please Don't Shoot The Messenger...
NICK FURY
HMMMMMMMMM… with a moderate progressive reverse spine roll or miss-wrap; What are the discoloration lines running parallel to the open edge to the right of his head?… water damage???? Of Concern: the black edge line that starts at the upper open edge disappears about 3/5th way down… not cut square???
And the pages that are visible show slight abrasion….???
|
Previous
Index
Next
Threaded
Edit
Reply
Quote
