<=(CLICK FOR THE MAIN SITE)

Goldcomics.com Forums Click here for the Main Site

MLJ Publishing (and Archie), 1939-1948 >> MLJ Comic book reviews

Pages: 1
kelsoModerator
Goldcomics Reviewer!
****

Reged: Jan 30 2003
Posts: 939
Loc: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania USA
Blue Ribbon #4
      #5139 - Tue May 24 2005 10:29 PM

Sometime back in late 1939-early 1940; Maurice Coyne, Louis Silberkleit, and John Goldwater took a very close look at the sales figures on the first three issue of Blue Ribbon Comics and found out that the title was in deep trouble sales wise. This very likely led to the unprecidented step of suspending publication on the title for a period of four months for a major overhaul. Of the strips that appeared in those first three issues, only two - Rang-A-Tang and Corporal Collins - were retained. The rest (with the exception of Bob Phantom who was moved to the pages of Top-Notch Comics) vanished into comic limbo. So when issue #4 (cover dated June, 1940) hit the stands in April of 1940, it was a much different book than it was before. So if one could get past that great Charles Biro cover (which also introduced the new title logo), here's what one found in the first issue of the revamped Blue Ribbon:

RANG-A-TANG; The now revamped title gets off to a good start as Rang-A-Tang and his master Hy Speed find themselves investigating a murder aboard a Panama Canal bound ocean liner. This story introduced the team that would guide comics answer to the legendary Rin-Tin-Tin for the rest of his run in Blue Ribbon, writer Joe Blair and artist Ed Smalle.

HERCULES; As a follow-up to the lead story, we get the comic book incarnation of the famed Greek demi-god. This Hercules was sent down to earth by Zeus to rid the world of crime. And his first labor was to go after ganglord Leo Nemia. The labors of Hercules, Modern Champion of Justice (the strip's full title) would continue until Blue Ribbon #8. Here Ed Wexler contributes the artwork.

GYPSY JOHNSON, ADVENTURER; In his first adventure, American Soldier of fortune Gypsy Johnson finds himself in the Foreign Legion trying to track down an elusive bandit chieftan. Gypsy Johnson's adventures would continue until issue #8.

THE FOX; Blue Ribbon's second superhero (and longest running superhero feature) is introduced in this tale that shows how photographer Paul Paxton adopted the identity of the Fox and his first battle against a gang of "night riders". Although Irwin Hasen's artwork leave much to be desired at this point (his style reminds me of Ed Wheelan's). It would tighten up (as would the Fox's costume) as the strip progressed. The Fox would continue to appear in Blue Ribbon up until the magazine's demise with March 1942's 22nd issue.

CORPORAL COLLINS; Here Corporal Collins and a group of men go rush to the aid of a besieged company in the desert about to be overrun by Nazis. This story introduced the good Corporal's sidekick Slapsie. Charles Biro contributed the art on this tale.

TY-GOR, SON OF THE TIGER; George Storm provides us with the origin and first adventure of a boy who was raised by tigers in the Malaysian jungles. The modern-day Mowgli would continue to appear in Blue Ribbon until issue #20.

DOC STRONG AND THE ISLE OF RIGHT; This offbeat feature gets off to a good start as Doc Strong gathers a group of people to move to an island to begin a new civilization and war against the tyranny of Mongol hordes that have overrun a post-apocalyptic world. This offbeat feature would continue until Blue Ribbon #12. Here Sam Cooper provides the artwork on this story.

LOOP LOGAN; For his first of 17 appearances in Blue Ribbon, Loop Logan answers the challenge of a top German air ace called the Blue Duke to a duel in the clouds.

THE GREEN FALCON; Like his contemporaries, Robin Hood and Wilfred of Ivanhoe, the Green Falcon waged war against the tyranny of Prince John. This story was how his personal crusade against Prince John began. Harry Shorten and Ed Ashe launched the green clad knight on his quest that would last until issue #15.

Looking at Blue Ribbon #4 it's safe to say that this was a good beginning for a title that had to undergo an extreme makeover for its survival. There would still be more tweaking to come for the title which would lead to the introductions of two notable superheroes - Mr. Justice and Captain Flag - later in the run. But this was only a new beginning for this title.

Shawn, keep up the good work and KEEP'EM FLYING!!!!!

Edited by Shield (Tue Jan 24 2006 10:50 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ShieldAdministrator
Administrator
***

Reged: Jan 27 2003
Posts: 1523
Loc: Worthington, Ohio
Re: Blue Ribbon #4
      #15342 - Wed May 25 2005 01:15 AM

Hi Kelso! To be honest, with the exception of Bob Phantom and WWII story references, I find Blue Ribbon 1-8 to be the very worst stuff MLJ put out. I appreciate your review; however those are just books that don't do it for me.

What I'd LOVE to hear you review is Blue Ribbon #9, especially the first Mr. Justice story. I think that book is a pretty good read as well!

Keep up the good work man! Once some time frees up, I'll give you access to some non-MLJ stuff.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Press Guardian
Total Newbie


Reged: May 17 2004
Posts: 19
Re: Blue Ribbon #4
      #15343 - Wed May 25 2005 07:34 PM

I've always enjoyed the pre Mr. Justice issues of Blue Ribbon. It could be just the funky nature of the comic. After all, how many superhero comics have a dog as the lead feature. Besides from an artwork standpoint you get to watch the development of not only Irwing Hasen, but also Mort Meskin and Charles Biro.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
kelsoModerator
Goldcomics Reviewer!
****

Reged: Jan 30 2003
Posts: 939
Loc: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania USA
Re: Blue Ribbon #4
      #15344 - Wed May 25 2005 10:45 PM

Y'know Shawn, you're right about the early issues of [i:b9239b062c]Blue Ribbon[/i:b9239b062c]. Looking at issues 1-8, I found that when compared to early issues of [i:b9239b062c]Pep[/i:b9239b062c], [i:b9239b062c]Top-Notch[/i:b9239b062c], and [i:b9239b062c]Zip[/i:b9239b062c]; the book was probably the weakest of MLJ's four anthologies. Other than the two Bob Phantom stories in issues 2 & 3 and some of the later Corporal Collins stories, those eight issues as a whole come off as somewhat lacklustre when compared to what MLJ was putting out in their other anthologies during this period. Even the Fox stories were hurt by Irwin Hasen's very loose early artwork.

I've reviewed [i:b9239b062c]Blue Ribbon[/i:b9239b062c] #9 a while back and I've got a chance to look it over again. Issue #9 was a far better read than the previous eight issues mainly because things really started happening in that book. First with the introduction of Mr. Justice; then with Corporal Collins' first team up with Sergeant Boyle; and finally with the emergence of Irwin Hasen's classic early style on the Fox. After that issue, the sky was the limit for that title as the introductions of Inferno and Captain Flag would prove.

As far as the [i:b9239b062c]Rang-A-Tang [/i:b9239b062c]strip goes, it was a decent strip but I never thought of it as lead feature material.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
pokey oakey
I was adored once too!
***

Reged: Aug 17 2003
Posts: 541
Re: Blue Ribbon #4
      #15345 - Wed May 25 2005 11:33 PM

My favorite issues were 9,16 and 22. I got sorta weepy when the little dog died in issue 22's Rang A Tang story. Don't get me wrong, I liked every one from 9 up, but if I had to choose three favorites those would be it.

--------------------
If it's not disclosed.....you're being hosed.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Pages: 1



Extra information
0 registered and 2 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Shield, kelso 

Print Topic

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Topic views: 586

Rate this topic

Jump to

Contact the Admin Your source for golden age comics and discussion!

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.2