<=(CLICK FOR THE MAIN SITE)

Goldcomics.com Forums Click here for the Main Site

MLJ Publishing (and Archie), 1939-1948 >> MLJ Comic book reviews

Pages: 1
kelsoModerator
Goldcomics Reviewer!
****

Reged: Jan 30 2003
Posts: 939
Loc: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania USA
Top-Notch #6
      #20736 - Mon Jan 30 2006 09:27 PM

By the time Top-Notch Comics #6 (cover dated June, 1940) hit the stands in April of 1940, it was in the middle of comics' very first cross-company storyline (the Mosconian Threat of Top-Notch #s 5-7 and Pep Comics #s 4 & 5). It also came in the middle of a tweaking period for Top-Notch as well. So if one could get past the classic Ed Ashe cover - which promotes the Galahad strip - here's what you would find inside:

THE WIZARD; the book gets of to a flying start as the Wizard renews his battle with the Mosconians as they try to destroy Boulder Dam. Watch for a sequence in which the Wizard perfoms a feat of super strength that rivals what Superman and Captain Marvel were doing at the time. Harry Shorten (story) and Ed Ashe (art) do an excellent job of continuing the Mosconian storyline.

GALAHAD; For his second Top-Notch appearance, Galahad goes on a quest to retrieve the Golden Chalice after it has been stolen by the wicked Earl of Pellam. Although Lin Streeter was no Hal Foster, he was quite able to capture the Prince Valiant feel in this story.

SHANGHAI SHERIDAN; In his second adventure, not only does Shanghai Sheridan renew his battle with warlord Wu Fang; Sheridan and his new ally Scary Dee have to rescue a pair of Americans from being taken prisoner by a Japanese battleship commander. Looking at this story, not only were Joe Blair (story) and Irving Novick (art) able to capture the Terry and the Pirates feel; Novick managed to draw the story in a manner reminicent of illustrator Noel Sickles (who incidently was Milt Caniff's chief influence).

STREAK CHANDLER; Once again Streak Chandler renews his battle with the tyranaical Kalox in story reminicent of what Alex Raymond was putting in his Flash Gordon pages at the time.

WINGS JOHNSON; Joe Blair and Ed Smalle once again bring you the adventures of Wings Johnson. Here Johnson not only leads a bombing run against a German war fleet, he also has to prevent a German raid on a British airbase. All in all, a decent little war story.

DICK STORM; Mort Meskin delivers the goods on the art in this story that has Dick Storm trying to overthrow a blood thirsty dictator in the country of Honduras.

BOB PHANTOM; Here Bob Phantom renews his battle with Ah Ku as he tries to destroy her drug smuggling operation. Here Harry Shorten (story) and Jerry Thorpe (art) deliver the goods on this fast paced thriller.

THE WEST POINTER; In this slice of college life, West Point cadet Keith Kornell teaches a bully from a rival school a lesson in sportsmanship. Ed Wexler delivers on the art.

KARDAK; The Master Brahmin storyline begins in earnest as Kardak and Lorna have their first encounter with the evil mystics. Harry Shorten (story) and C.F. Winter (art) came up with a storyline that rivaled what Lee Falk and Phil Davis were putting into their Mandrake the Magician strip.

For a book that was going through a tweaking period, Top-Notch Comics was quite an exceptional book. And considering what was ahead for the title, it was only the beginning.

Shawn, keep up the good work and KEEP 'EM FLYING!!!!!

Edited by kelso (Sat Feb 25 2006 12:04 AM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
pokey oakey
I was adored once too!
***

Reged: Aug 17 2003
Posts: 541
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: kelso]
      #20888 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:03 AM

Great review Kelso! I'm sure everybody already knows that Top Notch is My favorite non Archie MLJ and that I only need #35 to be at peace with the universe but do you know why? One reason is because I never read a mediocre issue between 1-27. The first Top Notch books I owned were Top Notch 9 and 7, I purchased them at the same time. Well let face it, they both had killer covers and the stories were great! So I was hooked. It's fun to read these reviews and to go back and reread these stories on this site.

--------------------
If it's not disclosed.....you're being hosed.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
***

Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: pokey oakey]
      #20889 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:06 AM

Too bad you don't have my copy!!

--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
pokey oakey
I was adored once too!
***

Reged: Aug 17 2003
Posts: 541
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: Timulty]
      #20891 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:09 AM

Ar you trying to ?

--------------------
If it's not disclosed.....you're being hosed.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
kelsoModerator
Goldcomics Reviewer!
****

Reged: Jan 30 2003
Posts: 939
Loc: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania USA
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: pokey oakey]
      #20893 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:22 AM

Y'know Pokey, that was the one thing I found out about those 27 issues of Top-Notch when I began reading those issues. Even during that tweaking period I mentioned for the title, it was very hard to find ANY strip that was without any merit at all. The reason being is that when MLJ christened their second anthology title Top-Notch Comics , they made every effort to live up to the dictionary meaning of the term "top notch" which means of the highest quality. Even the non-superhero backup features had more than some merit to them.

My favorites of the non-superhero backup features in Top-Notch were Shanghai Sheridan (due in large part to Irv Novick's atmospheric artwork), Fran Frazier, and Keith Kornell, the West Pointer.

Edited by kelso (Wed Feb 01 2006 12:24 AM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
pokey oakey
I was adored once too!
***

Reged: Aug 17 2003
Posts: 541
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: kelso]
      #20894 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:29 AM

I remeber how sad I got when I read the Firefly story in issue 27 and it was a "to be comtinued " story.

--------------------
If it's not disclosed.....you're being hosed.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Timulty
Be careful what you say...
***

Reged: Oct 12 2005
Posts: 824
Loc: Fawcett City
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: pokey oakey]
      #20899 - Wed Feb 01 2006 07:46 AM

Quote:

Ar you trying to ?




Hell's yeah, I am I have been looking for a copy for a couple monthes. It is a frustrating endeavor but I sense that next month, one will surface. Perhaps, more. I am trying to get this one for a friend, anyhow. He's been looking forever.

--------------------
Old coinees never die, they wisen up and become comic book collectors!!!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
pokey oakey
I was adored once too!
***

Reged: Aug 17 2003
Posts: 541
Re: Top-Notch #6 [Re: Timulty]
      #20910 - Wed Feb 01 2006 12:35 PM

It's funny, I passed up 3 or 4 of them on ebay because they weren't a priority early on. My grails use to ne TN13 and then TN26. I never thought that TNL 31 and 35 would become grails. TNL 31 was somewhwat important because of the second part of the Black Hood story. TNL35 is rumoured to be significant because of a fishing story with Poke Oakey and his buddy Clem that is said to have inspired Brokeback mountain. (Satan's Prodigy may be interested in that aspect of it )

--------------------
If it's not disclosed.....you're being hosed.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Pages: 1



Extra information
0 registered and 1 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Shield, kelso 

Print Topic

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Topic views: 831

Rate this topic

Jump to

Contact the Admin Your source for golden age comics and discussion!

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.2