Is there ever a case in which an almost 2 and a half inch spine split (entire bottom left up to the bottom staple) would ever grade a VG/FN 5.0???
Even if the rest of the book were perfect and that was the only flaw?
I would put this at a FR/GD 1.5 myself and according to the Overstreet CB Grading guide.
I got it in a batch of others and didn't get a chance to properly check it then and now I'm fuming. Only lost about 15 bucks on it but it is a low # JLA and I'm very dissapointed. I'm thinking of calling him and asking him about it but I'd like a few more opinions first.